looking beyond borders

foreign policy and global economy

Archive for the category “India”

India Needs A New Story

Taken together, domestic economic management, recent political and geopolitical choices made at home, the regional and global consequences of Trump and Trumpism, the geo-economics and geo-politics of China’s rise, are all beginning to pose a challenge to the extant Rising India narrative. The old narrative is taking a beating. A new narrative can only be built on the foundations of improved economic performance and better management of domestic political challenges.

Read Here – The Indian Express


Putting Dogmas Behind A Starting Point For India

A nation that has the aspiration to become a leading power someday cannot continue with unsettled borders, an unintegrated region and under-exploited opportunities. Above all, it cannot be dogmatic in approaching a visibly changing global order. Napoleon once said that history is a version of past events that people have decided to agree upon. The world that awaits us not only calls for fresh thinking, but eventually, a new consensus at home as well. Putting dogmas behind us is a starting point for that journey, says India’s Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar.

Read Here – Indian Ministry of External Affairs

Chinese Sharp Power: Is Beijing Influencing Public Opinion In India?

Beijing’s attempts to build lucrative relationships with a diverse array of Indian political leaders require serious attention, considering how severely such suspiciously developed relationships have impacted domestic debates on China in other countries.

Read Here – ORF

Can India’s Prime Minister Succeed Even As The Economy Plummets?

The dominance of the BJP, however, has surprisingly little do with its economic track record. Modi has succeeded politically despite—not because of—the economy, which is in the midst of a protracted downturn that began on his watch. For his second term, the prime minister has doubled down on the grand economic promises he made in his 2014 campaign and gone still further, setting a goal of turning India into a $5 trillion economy by 2024. But his government has struggled to articulate just how it will bring about India’s economic renewal.

Read Here – Foreign Affairs

Might India Start The Next South Asia Crisis?

Instead of an attack in India that initiates crisis, what if one arose following a proactive Indian operation to seize territory over the Line of Control (LOC) in the portion of the disputed territory of Kashmir controlled by Pakistan? Indian leaders have contemplated such operations in the past, and the current government in India has demonstrated its willingness to take considerable risks, including in the February 2019 crisis.

Read Here – WarOnTheRocks

India Turns Its Back On Freer Trade

World leaders at the 3rd RCEP Summit in Bangkok, Thailand on November 04, 2019. Photo/PIB

India, which has for some years now been raising walls against the rest of the world, appears to have definitively turned its back on freer trade. Fifteen of the 16 countries involved in negotiations agreed on Nov. 4 to sign up to the giant trade agreement known as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership. Only India, after months of uncertainty, chose to hold back for the foreseeable future.

Read Here – Bloomberg

Modi Says India Values Saudi’s Vital Role

On the occasion of his visit to Saudi Arabia, his second in three years, India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi said  that the two countries have been working together within the G20 to reduce inequality and promote sustainable development.
Modi said with the signing of an agreement on a Strategic Partnership Council, already robust and deep bilateral ties in various fields will only strengthen further. Saying stable oil prices are crucial for the growth of the global economy, he praised the Kingdom’s role as an important and reliable source of India’s energy requirements.

Read Here – Arab News

Also Read: MBS’s Reform-Driven Saudi Offers India Room To Strengthen Bilateral Ties

In China’s Hierarchical Worldview India Stands Very Low, And That’s Unlikely To Change

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Mamallapuram, Tamil Nadu on October 12, 2019. Photo/PIB

In 1996, Jiang Zemin became the first Chinese head of state to visit India, underscoring the journey the two Asian neighbours had made since their 1962 border war. His successor Hu Jintao came calling in 2006.

However, when you compare that to Xi Jinping’s three visits to India in the past five years – the last earlier this month to Mamallapuram — and his several meetings with the Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in China, India and other countries, you realise how much the ties between the two neighbours have seemingly improved.

From India’s point of view such interactions are extremely important. Staying engaged means the chances of slowly reducing the decades-old trust deficit between the two neighbours are higher.

There are also more opportunities for India to raise its concerns with Beijing about Pakistan, about the huge unfavourable bilateral trade deficit, and about everything else about the world that matters to New Delhi.

It also means that China continues to be interested in India beyond the long border dispute between the two. And that is a huge change from a time when Beijing cared little, if at all, about India. The shift has been slow, and mostly triggered by India’s economic growth that really started from the early part of this century.

However, we must not also forget that Xi hosted Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan just before leaving for India and then travelled to Nepal for an official visit — the first by a Chine president to the land-locked Himalayan kingdom — after his meeting with Modi.

A curious China has followed India for its technological brainpower, its growing market that can be tapped — a massive $65 billion trade surplus is a good indicator — and an economy that at one point touched double digit growth. At the same time, Beijing has also watched India become closer to the United States at a time when its own trade relations with Washington are at their highest.

However, it is hardly a relationship that can be called equal. If at all, China is still patronising — the big brother in the neighbourhood keeping a close eye on India’s growth and ambitions, but at the same time allowing It some space and me time so that the two can stay engaged in a world that is very different from 1962 when they fought a border war.

Xi made it clear during the visit that the informal summits between him and Prime Minister Narendra Modi were at the request of the latter. In short, what he meant was that he was happy to oblige India with meetings, photo-ops and seaside conversations about how best bilateral issues can be addressed. It works well for both leaders in the social media age when selfies are an important part of our lives.

Whether China is really keen to resolve the old border or the new bilateral trade deficit issue quickly is a question that is still on the table and likely to there for longer. And since it is an unequal relationship, India can only continue to wait patiently for the needle to move. Breathe slowly, and breathe long.

Let’s not forget Doklam, where Chinese troops pushed the Indian army around even as Xi shared a traditional Indian swing with Modi in Ahmedabad for a conversation and ruffled diplomatic feathers.

China always takes a long-term view of things — a glacial, civilisational approach that many in the world mistake as slow decision-making. But let’s remember to do nothing is as much a decision as doing something.

The civilisational trap

And so we get into the 100-year civilisations trap, which in reality means status quo. That serves China well, as India is not a political or an economic threat in any way and China currently has enough of its problems to worry about — from a slowing economy to a dying Hong Kong.

Despite all its own problems, China still weighs heavy on India and the world. Its economy is at least four times bigger than that of India. So while Indians can celebrate their economy growing at a pace faster than China’s at certain points in history, the reality is that it would still take India a few decades to reach where China currently is. That also has geopolitical ramifications.

India might be a rising star, but it still doesn’t have the geo-economic heft to make a real difference to the world. That ability to influence things beyond its borders would only come once India’s economy gets on the treadmill and somebody presses 10, or probably 12. That, unfortunately, isn’t happening very soon.

And while it may be a nuclear power; India is not a big military power. It still relies heavily on imports of arms and armaments to be able to flex its muscles. China, on the other hand, produces everything it needs from guns to planes and is a growing exporter of military hardware.

And we are not even talking about Pakistan, China’s all-weather friend. Beijing will continues to hold its hands for more reasons than those that concern India. The fact that Xi hosted both Khan and Pakistan military chief General Qamar Bajwa just before he dropped in to shake hands with Modi is a clear indication of its priorities.

In short, India doesn’t really have very strong bargaining powers with China and can only push for small shifts that Beijing is happy to allow, but never without taking something back. Negotiations, though seen in India’s favour in the short term, don’t always mean they will benefit New Delhi in the long run.

So while Indian exports to China will grow, the big question is what is it that Beijing is getting in return for opening its door slightly more? Will India allow Chinese companies to sell their 5G telecom technology despite objections from the United States and fears over data security? Time will tell.

It would be very interesting to know how Modi sold the political changes in Kashmir triggered by the revocation of the constitution’s Article 370 to Xi. Let’s remember, China was gunning for India post New Delhi’s decision to change the political set up of Jammu and Kashmir. Xi generally waved that off during that visit. So what happened?

The reality is that China might allow administrative tinkering in Ladhakh as long as it doesn’t feel the move could potentially disturb the other key political fault lines — the 4,00 km-long border as it exists. If it does view the changes as ones that will disturb the status quo we could expect another Doklam-like situation, or maybe more stronger arm-twisting and threats that would definitely disturb the calm seas seen at Mamallapuram.

More importantly, China will definitely wait for future opportunities to push India back diplomatically. It is not in its interest to see India rise. In its hierarchical worldview, India is much lower in the political, diplomatic, economic and cultural ladder than others. That is unlikely to change for a long time.

India, therefore, needs to be smart and prepared to finds ways to push China back, whether by aligning itself strategically deeper with powers as concerned about Beijing’s ambitions or by growing economically at a rate that makes Beijing to continue to appreciate and eventually reconcile to India’s ambitions and growth. China will only agree to play a mutually beneficial game with a strong India.

The Awkward Elephant In The Room When Xi And Modi Meet

File Photo/PIB

Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to India next month might look like a landmark moment in the warming of relations between the two countries. But look a little closer and one seemingly intractable obstacle remains: Xi’s signature

Belt and Road Initiative. The plan remains a thorny issue in relations.

‘Howdy, Modi!’: Trump Hails Indian PM At ‘Historic’ Texas Rally

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi with the President of United States of America Donald Trump at a rally in Houston on September 22, 2019. Photo/PIB

US President Donald Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi exchanged warm words of friendship in Texas at a rare mass rally for a foreign leader. Around 50,000 people gathered for what Mr Trump called a “profoundly historic event” on Sunday in Houston. The “Howdy, Modi!” event was billed as one of the largest ever receptions of a foreign leader in the US.

Read Here – BBC

Post Navigation

%d bloggers like this: